Here's the thing about convection toaster ovens: once you have a good one, you'll wonder why you ever fired up a full-size oven for a single chicken breast. Your big oven takes 15 minutes just to preheat. A convection toaster oven is ready in three. And the results — crispier skin, more even browning, actually edible reheated pizza — are often better.
We tested 18+ models over several weeks. Toast, banana bread, roasted broccoli, frozen wings, leftover lasagna. We ran each oven through the same tasks and paid attention to what actually mattered: how even the heat was, how honest the temperature dial was, how annoying the cleanup got. Some ovens surprised us. A couple were genuinely bad. These five are the ones we'd actually buy.
Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
#1 — Breville Smart Oven Pro BOV845BSS
We've put a lot of toaster ovens through their paces. The Breville Smart Oven Pro is the one that keeps winning. It has five independent quartz heating elements — Breville calls it Element IQ — and unlike most marketing claims, this one holds up. Switch from toast to roast and the heat distribution actually shifts to match. Our banana bread came out with an even rise and clean edges, no scorching. Six slices of toast browned corner to corner, all six identical. That doesn't happen with most ovens at any price. The 0.8 cubic foot interior is legitimately roomy: a 13-inch pizza lays flat, a 9x13 baking dish slides in without a fight, and we roasted a 6-pound chicken with clearance on all sides. The slow cook mode isn't a gimmick either — we did a short rib braise for 8 hours and it came out properly tender. Small things matter too: the door closes with a real click, the knobs have weight to them, and the interior light means you're not cracking the door every five minutes to check on things. It's the most expensive oven on this list. That's the only honest complaint. If you cook more than a few times a week and you're tired of uneven results, just buy this one.
Pros
- Element IQ distributes heat intelligently across 5 quartz elements
- 10 cooking functions including slow cook
- 0.8 cu ft — fits 13" pizza or 9x13 pan
- Exceptionally even toast and baking results
- Interior oven light for monitoring food
- Non-stick easy-clean interior
- Premium stainless steel build quality
- Includes pizza pan, broil rack, and baking pan
Cons
- Premium price — most expensive on this list
- Large footprint requires significant counter space
- No air fry function (unlike some competitors)
Best for: Home cooks who want the best all-around countertop oven and bake or roast regularly.
#2 — Cuisinart TOA-60 AirFryer Toaster Oven
Plenty of toaster ovens slap "air fry" on the box and deliver glorified convection. The TOA-60 isn't that. We loaded 12 chicken wings onto the rack — crowded, the way you'd actually cook them — and they came out with real crunch. Not the pale, soft result you get from a regular oven. Frozen fries were done in 14 minutes and didn't need flipping. Breaded shrimp browned evenly, no soggy patches. It's not quite as aggressive as a dedicated basket-style air fryer, but it's close enough that you won't miss having a separate machine taking up counter space. The 0.6 cubic foot interior handles a 12-inch pizza or a whole small chicken. Seven cooking functions cover the basics without overwhelming you. The controls are physical dials — you turn them, things happen, no touchscreen to fumble with when your hands are covered in flour. One thing to know: the exterior gets genuinely warm during use. Don't push it flush against your cabinets. Give it a few inches of clearance on all sides. At $199, it's the right call if you're currently running a toaster oven and an air fryer as two separate appliances.
Pros
- Dedicated air fry mode with genuinely crispy results
- 7 cooking functions in one appliance
- 0.6 cu ft — fits 12" pizza or whole chicken
- Replaces both toaster oven and air fryer
- Intuitive dial controls
- Includes air fry rack, baking pan, and oven rack
- Strong value at ~$199
Cons
- Air fry basket smaller than dedicated air fryers
- No interior light
- Runs hot on the exterior — keep clearance around it
Best for: Anyone who wants to consolidate their air fryer and toaster oven into one capable countertop appliance.
#3 — Ninja Foodi XL Pro Air Oven
Once you're cooking for four or more people, the other ovens on this list start feeling small. The Ninja Foodi XL Pro doesn't have that problem. We fit two 12-inch pizzas side by side with room between them. A full sheet pan of roasted vegetables — the kind you'd normally commit a real oven to — slid straight in. A 5-pound chicken sat with clearance on all sides. Capacity is the whole point here, and it delivers. The convection fan is noticeably strong; preheat was faster than both the Cuisinart and the Breville, and browning stayed even all the way to the edges of the sheet pan. Air fry results are solid — on par with the TOA-60 — and the bigger interior means you're not stuck cooking wings in two separate batches. The flip-up design is the other thing worth mentioning. When you're done, the oven folds up against the wall and your counter comes back. It feels awkward the first couple of times. By day three it's automatic. Cleanup is straightforward: non-stick interior, sheet pan and rack both go in the dishwasher. $249 isn't cheap, but for a household that cooks real meals every day, it pulls its weight.
Pros
- XL capacity — fits two 12" pizzas or a full sheet pan
- 8 cooking functions including air fry and dehydrate
- Flip-up design saves counter space when not in use
- Powerful convection fan for fast, even cooking
- Non-stick interior and dishwasher-safe accessories
- Strong air fry performance for a toaster oven
Cons
- Large overall footprint even when flipped up
- Flip mechanism takes some getting used to
- Exterior gets warm — needs ventilation clearance
Best for: Families of 4–6 who need large-capacity cooking and want air fry capability in the same appliance.
#4 — BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSB
Seventy-nine dollars. That's what this costs, and it's a convection oven that actually works. We weren't expecting much — budget appliances in this category usually disappoint — but the TO3250XSB surprised us. Toast came out even. Cookies baked without burnt bottoms. A 9x13 dish of roasted potatoes browned properly, not just on the edges. The convection fan makes a real difference over non-convection models at the same price; you can see it in the results. Eight cooking functions handle everything you'd realistically need day-to-day. The dials are physical and simple — there's nothing to figure out. The interior fits a 12-inch pizza or a 9x13 baking dish, which makes it a solid secondary oven when your main oven is occupied. It's not precise. Temperature can drift a bit, and you'll want to check on things a few minutes early the first couple of times. The build quality is plastic-heavy and feels it. There's no interior light. But none of that matters much at $79. If you're new to convection cooking or just need something reliable without spending real money, this is the one.
Pros
- Excellent value at ~$79
- 8-slice / 12" pizza capacity
- 8 cooking functions for everyday needs
- Simple, intuitive dial controls
- Fits a 9x13 baking dish
- Convection fan improves evenness over non-convection rivals
Cons
- Less precise temperature control than premium models
- No interior light
- Build quality reflects the budget price point
- No air fry function
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers, first-time convection oven owners, or anyone needing a reliable secondary oven.
#5 — Panasonic FlashXpress NB-G110P
The FlashXpress doesn't have a convection fan. Instead it uses two types of infrared heating — near and far — that work simultaneously from above and below. The practical effect is speed. Real, noticeable speed. Toast is done in about 60 seconds. Frozen waffles crisp up in under two minutes. A slice of cold pizza reheats in three minutes with a bottom crust that's actually crispy, not soggy — which is something most toaster ovens genuinely struggle with. We tested it back-to-back against the BLACK+DECKER on pizza reheating and it wasn't close. The FlashXpress won every time. The tradeoff is size. The interior fits a 9-inch pizza and not much else. Don't plan on roasting a chicken or baking a full batch of cookies in here. It's a machine built for fast, everyday tasks — toast, reheating, frozen snacks — and at those tasks it's the best we've tested. The six presets are one-touch and accurate. The digital timer is precise. Cleanup is easy. At $99 it's a smart buy for anyone with a small kitchen, a dorm room, or an office break room that deserves better than a microwave.
Pros
- Double infrared heating — exceptionally fast cooking
- Outstanding browning and crispiness
- Compact footprint — ideal for small kitchens
- One-touch presets for common tasks
- Reheats pizza with a genuinely crispy crust
- Precise digital timer controls
Cons
- Small interior — fits 9" pizza maximum
- Not suitable for roasting or large baking tasks
- No convection fan (uses infrared instead)
- Limited to 6 cooking functions
Best for: Small kitchens, singles, dorm rooms, or anyone who prioritizes speed and crispiness over capacity.
Convection Toaster Oven Buying Guide
Capacity: This is the first thing to figure out. For one or two people, a 0.4–0.5 cu ft model handles a 9–10 inch pizza and most everyday tasks. For three or four people, you want 0.6–0.8 cu ft — that's 12–13 inch pizza territory, and it fits a 9x13 baking dish. Families of five or more should look at 0.9 cu ft and up, or just go straight to the Ninja Foodi XL.
Convection vs. infrared: Convection uses a fan to push hot air around your food. It's great for even baking, roasting, and anything where you want consistent browning across the whole surface. Infrared — like the Panasonic FlashXpress — uses radiant heat and cooks faster with excellent crisping, but it's less suited to baking. Both beat a standard toaster oven. Pick based on what you cook most.
Air fry combo: If you're thinking about replacing your air fryer, don't just look for the words "air fry" on the box. Look for a dedicated air fry mode and a proper air fry rack included in the box. The Cuisinart TOA-60 and Ninja Foodi XL Pro both have real air fry performance. A lot of cheaper models don't.
Heating elements: More elements means more even cooking. The Breville's five-element system is the best we've tested. Most budget models use two to four elements, which is fine for everyday use but shows its limits on larger baking tasks.
Temperature range: You want at least 150°F on the low end for warming and dehydrating, and 450°F on the high end for broiling and pizza. A wider range gives you more flexibility. Check the spec sheet — some budget models top out at 425°F, which isn't a dealbreaker but worth knowing.
Accessories: A baking pan and wire rack should come standard. If you're buying an air fry model, it should include an air fry basket or rack — don't assume it does. The Breville includes a pizza pan, broil rack, and baking pan. The Cuisinart and Ninja both include their air fry racks. The BLACK+DECKER keeps it basic but covers the essentials.
Who Should Buy Which
- Best all-around: Breville Smart Oven Pro BOV845BSS — the most precise, most versatile, and best-built countertop oven on this list. Worth every dollar if you cook regularly.
- Best air fryer combo: Cuisinart TOA-60 — replaces both your toaster oven and air fryer without compromise. The smart choice if counter space is limited.
- Best for large families: Ninja Foodi XL Pro Air Oven — XL capacity handles big batches, and the flip-up design reclaims counter space when you're done.
- Best on a budget: BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSB — reliable convection performance at a price that's hard to argue with. Great starter oven.
- Best for small kitchens: Panasonic FlashXpress NB-G110P — compact, lightning-fast, and produces the crispiest reheated pizza you've ever had from a countertop appliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does convection actually do in a toaster oven?
Convection adds a fan that circulates hot air around your food. This eliminates hot spots, speeds up cooking by 20–30%, and produces better browning and crispiness compared to a standard toaster oven that relies on radiant heat alone. For baking, roasting, and anything where you want a crispy exterior, convection makes a noticeable difference.
Can a convection toaster oven replace a full-size oven?
For most everyday cooking tasks — yes. Baking, roasting, broiling, reheating, and toasting all work excellently in a convection toaster oven, often better than a full-size oven because the smaller cavity heats up faster and more evenly. Where they fall short is large-batch cooking: a full-size oven can handle multiple racks of cookies or a large turkey. For a household of 1–4 people, a quality convection toaster oven handles 80–90% of cooking needs.
Do I need to adjust recipes for convection cooking?
Yes, slightly. Convection cooks faster and more evenly than conventional heat. As a general rule, reduce the temperature by 25°F or reduce the cooking time by about 20% when converting a conventional recipe. For toasting and reheating, no adjustment is needed — just watch your food the first few times to calibrate to your specific model.
Is a convection toaster oven the same as an air fryer?
They use the same basic principle — a fan circulating hot air — but air fryers run hotter, circulate air more aggressively, and use a perforated basket that allows airflow from all sides. This produces crispier results for fried foods. Convection toaster ovens are more versatile (better for baking and roasting) but less aggressive at crisping. Models like the Cuisinart TOA-60 and Ninja Foodi XL Pro bridge the gap with dedicated air fry modes.
How do I clean a convection toaster oven?
Let it cool completely first. Remove and wash the racks, pans, and crumb tray with warm soapy water — most are dishwasher safe. Wipe the interior with a damp cloth or non-abrasive sponge; avoid harsh chemicals that can damage non-stick coatings. The crumb tray should be emptied after every few uses to prevent burning smells and fire risk. For stubborn grease, a paste of baking soda and water left for 15 minutes works well.